MediaMeter Knowledge Base

News values and story strength

How editors decide what is news: Galtung and Ruge's classic factors, David Randall's eight values, and why "say stories" sit at the bottom of the scale.

Every editorial decision — cover it or not, front page or inside page, lead or brief — is a judgement about news value. Two complementary frameworks describe it: Galtung and Ruge’s sociological analysis of how foreign news gets selected, and David Randall’s practical scale of story strength.

Galtung and Ruge: why some events become news

In 1965, Johan Galtung and Mari Holmboe Ruge analysed crisis coverage and identified recurring selection factors — essentially psychological buttons that make an event feel newsworthy:

  • Frequency — events that fit the news cycle (a murder fits a daily paper; a slow famine does not).
  • Threshold — big events beat small ones; intensity matters.
  • Unambiguity — clear, simple stories travel; murky complexity gets ignored.
  • Meaningfulness — cultural proximity and familiarity to the audience.
  • Consonance — events that match expectations and existing narratives are selected more often.
  • Unexpectedness — within the meaningful, the surprising wins.
  • Continuity — once a story is “running,” it keeps running.
  • Composition — editors balance the day’s mix (foreign/domestic, heavy/light).
  • Elite nations and elite people — powerful countries and famous individuals dominate coverage regardless of proportion.
  • Negativity — bad news passes filters that good news does not. Negativity bias is measurable and exploited by attention-optimised platforms.

The lesson for a modern reader: news selection is not a mirror of importance. A responsible editor consciously counterweights the buttons — covering slow, complex, far-away stories the buttons would drop.

Randall’s eight factors: judging an individual story

David Randall (The Universal Journalist) evaluates story strength on eight sliding factors: subject, news fashion, development, source, knowledge, timing, readers, and context. A story gains strength when it has an important subject, fresh development, an authoritative source, new knowledge, timeliness, relevance to its readers, and the context to interpret it.

Randall’s key insight is the hierarchy of story types. At the bottom sits the “say story” — an account of what someone said, which costs nothing to produce and proves nothing happened (a press release, a politician’s claim, a spokesperson’s statement). Above it rank reports of events, and at the top, journalism that produces evidence the actors did not want published. Editors should ask of every item: is this reporting something that happened, or just something that was said?

Applying it in a newsroom

  • Test each idea against both frameworks: does it score on substance (Randall) or merely on psychological buttons (Galtung)?
  • Distrust stories selected purely by consonance — “the narrative people already believe” is where error and bias live.
  • Track your say-story ratio. A page dominated by claims and announcements is a page doing little original reporting.
  • When a story is weak, the honest options are: deepen the reporting, write it as a brief, or spike it — not to inflate the headline.

MediaMeter context: this distinction is built into the content-type taxonomy — “report of an event,” “report of a claim,” and “explainer” carry different required elements and different assessment emphases, because what a good story is differs by type.

Last reviewed: October 20, 2026. Part of the MediaMeter knowledge base — editorial reference material, not product documentation.

More from the knowledge base

The ten elements of journalism

Kovach and Rosenstiel's principles for journalism that serves citizens: truth, verification, independence, and the watchdog role — and why they matter more online, not less.

Journalism ethics codes compared

SPJ, NUJ, IFJ, AFP, Reuters, the German Pressekodex and the UK's IPSO code: what the major ethics frameworks require, where they agree, and where they differ.