MediaMeter Knowledge Base

Fact-check evidence sources and tiers

The twelve specified evidence sources, the T1–T6 credibility model, and the two-independent-sources rule every verdict must meet. Part of the MediaMeter specification.

Specification reference

This describes the fact-check evidence model in our specification — the sources and rules a verdict must satisfy. Design, not deployed capability.

A verdict is only as good as its evidence chain. Our specification fixes both where evidence comes from and the minimum bar a TRUE or FALSE finding must clear.

The credibility model

Evidence sources are ranked in tiers by their institutional reliability and verifiability:

Tier Class Examples from our registry
T1 Highest-credibility primary and reference sources IPCC reports; government statistical services (World Bank, WHO, Eurostat, NOAA); IFCN-signatory fact-checks; Google Fact Check Tools
T2–T3 Strong academic and reference sources PubMed, Semantic Scholar, Wikidata/DBpedia
T4–T5 News and aggregators GDELT, news APIs — usable for discovery and context, not for verdict-level proof
T6 Low-credibility material Unverified claims, circular reporting — never verdict-supporting

The twelve specified sources

Source Type Class Status
Google Fact Check Tools API API aggregator enabled
IFCN Signatory Fact-Checks API factcheck enabled
Wikidata / DBpedia (SPARQL) SPARQL reference enabled
World Bank Open Data API government enabled
WHO Global Health Observatory API government enabled
Eurostat API government enabled
NOAA API government enabled
IPCC Reports scrape academic enabled
PubMed API academic enabled
Semantic Scholar API academic enabled
GDELT Project API news enabled
NewsAPI API news disabled — pending licence review

The rules a verdict must satisfy

  • Two-source rule — a TRUE or FALSE verdict requires at least two independent T1–T3 sources. Two outlets repeating the same wire count as one; the error code FACTCHECK_SOURCE_COUNT_BELOW_THRESHOLD fires when the rule can’t be met.
  • Evidence-chain publication — every verdict carries the claims, the sources considered, and the reasoning — so a reader can check the same evidence the system did.
  • Human review for high-stakes findings — FALSE and MISLEADING verdicts require a human reviewer before publication.
  • Honest uncertainty — where sources disagree or fall short, the verdict is UNVERIFIABLE, not a coin-flip guess.

Retrieval is specified as hybrid (lexical BM25 + dense semantic similarity, multilingual-e5 embeddings) with deduplication thresholds — because the first verification problem is often finding the prior fact-check or primary document, not judging it.

Last reviewed: October 20, 2026. Part of the MediaMeter knowledge base — editorial reference material, not product documentation.

More from the knowledge base

The ten elements of journalism

Kovach and Rosenstiel's principles for journalism that serves citizens: truth, verification, independence, and the watchdog role — and why they matter more online, not less.

Journalism ethics codes compared

SPJ, NUJ, IFJ, AFP, Reuters, the German Pressekodex and the UK's IPSO code: what the major ethics frameworks require, where they agree, and where they differ.

News values and story strength

How editors decide what is news: Galtung and Ruge's classic factors, David Randall's eight values, and why "say stories" sit at the bottom of the scale.