Investigative method
Chronologies, documents, the right-of-reply letter, teamwork, and cross-border publication — the working method behind public-interest investigations, from Watergate to the Panama Papers.
David Leigh defined investigative journalism as “the supply of truths that others want hidden.” It is also, he notes, the hardest kind to publish — because the facts are only half the job. The other half is surviving the legal, financial, and political pressure that follows.
The working method
1. Build the chronology first
Leigh’s bedrock rule: a single, searchable chronology of every fact, document, and event — dated and sourced — before drawing any conclusion. Complex investigations fail when researchers hold the story in their heads instead of on a timeline where contradictions show.
2. Test a case theory, don’t hunt a headline
Form a working hypothesis, then hunt the documents that would disprove it. Imagination generates the theory; evidence either survives it or doesn’t. Never publish on theory alone.
3. Documents and data beat quotes
Filings, registers, lawsuits, contracts, procurement records, leaked datasets — public-record tools (Companies House, Land Registry, court files, FOIA, subject-access requests) produce checkable evidence. Human sources point the way; documents prove it.
4. Question every human source
Every informant has a motive — revenge, ideology, vanity, money. Ask what they know directly vs. what they heard, check their consistency over time, and corroborate with material evidence. A controlled source is a compromised story.
5. The right-of-reply letter
Before publication, send the subject a numbered list of the specific allegations, a statement of public interest, and a real deadline. It is both ethics and armour: fairness is a legal defence, and the response often contains new information. Keep the timestamped email trail.
6. Work in pairs, teams, and consortia
The “lessons of Watergate” start with working in pairs — for checking, for legal support, and for morale when people hate you. Modern leaks and cross-border cases (Panama Papers, ICIJ projects) work only as consortia with simultaneous publication — a tactic that defeats injunctions, because suppressing one outlet no longer suppresses the story.
The ethics floor
- Cruel but fair — fairness means never distorting the facts; it does not mean softening true findings into false balance.
- Public interest, defined — the UK DPP guidelines give a working test: does the story expose a crime, a failure to meet a legal obligation, a miscarriage of justice, a matter of important public debate, or a concealment of these? If not, rethink the target.
- No payment for information — paying sources discredits their evidence and your story.
- Deception is a last resort — Kovach and Rosenstiel’s masquerade test: the information must be vital to the public interest, there must be no other way to get it, and the deception must be disclosed to the audience.
- Publish prominently — impact stimulates fresh sources; a buried investigation protects the subject.
MediaMeter context: our specification treats investigative work as its own content type with required elements (chronology evidence, right-of-reply documentation, methodology disclosure) — because the hallmarks of a rigorous investigation are checkable properties of the published piece.
Last reviewed: October 20, 2026. Part of the MediaMeter knowledge base — editorial reference material, not product documentation.