MediaMeter Knowledge Base

Media law essentials for journalists

Defamation and its defences, privilege, contempt of court, the Reynolds test, and jigsaw identification — the legal floor every publisher stands on. UK, US, and EU framing.

This is an educational overview, not legal advice. Media law varies by jurisdiction and changes; for a specific story, consult a media lawyer.

Media law answers one question: what can be published without creating legal liability? The four recurring areas are defamation, privacy, contempt, and copyright — plus the protection frameworks (privilege, public-interest defences, shield laws) that make public-interest journalism possible.

Defamation

A statement is defamatory if it is published, identifies a person, and lowers their reputation in the eyes of reasonable people. The claimant’s burden and available defences differ sharply by system:

  • US — plaintiffs must prove falsity and fault; public figures must show actual malice (knowledge of falsity or reckless disregard). The First Amendment gives the press its widest legal protection anywhere.
  • UK — historically claimant-friendly; the Defamation Act 2013 requires serious harm and codifies defences: truth, honest opinion, publication on a matter of public interest, and privilege.
  • Germany/EU — reputation rights (Ehre) weigh heavily against press freedom; statements of fact must be demonstrably true, while Meinungsfreiheit (opinion) is protected if not gratuitously insulting (Schmähkritik).

The Reynolds/Nicholls test: public-interest journalism

The UK’s Reynolds defence (now largely the statutory s.4 public-interest defence) protects responsible journalism even when a story turns out to be wrong. Lord Nicholls’ ten factors ask: was the allegation serious? was the subject matter of public concern? were sources credible? was verification attempted? was the subject’s side reported fairly? was the tone responsible? was urgency justified? did the article include the gist of the subject’s response?

The operational lesson: the defence is earned in the newsroom, not the courtroom. Put allegations to the subject, record their response, document verification — before publication.

Privilege

Absolute privilege protects fair, accurate, contemporaneous reports of court proceedings and parliamentary debates — you can publish them even when they contain defamatory statements, because the public interest in open justice is absolute. Qualified privilege covers fair and accurate reports of official proceedings, public meetings, councils, tribunals, and press conferences — conditional on including the subject’s explanation or contradiction.

Contempt of court

In the UK, once proceedings are active (arrest, charge, warrant), publishing material that creates a substantial risk of serious prejudice is a strict-liability offence — no intent needed. Safe practice in active cases: report only the charges, basic facts, and what is said in open court; never publish a defendant’s criminal record, speculation about guilt, or evidence not yet heard.

Jigsaw identification

Reporting restrictions protect complainants in sexual offences and children in court cases. Publishing different details across outlets can combine to identify a protected person — each detail alone is legal, the combination is not. Check what other outlets have already published before adding identifying details.

Other recurring exposures

  • Copyright — protection is automatic on creation; quotation is only lawful within narrow exceptions (UK fair dealing, US fair use, German Zitatrecht) — attribute and keep quotes proportionate.
  • Privacy — misuse of private information (UK), publication of private facts (US), Persönlichkeitsrecht (Germany): private facts need a public-interest justification, strongest for public figures acting in public roles.
  • SLAPP suits — strategic lawsuits against public participation aim to exhaust defendants through process cost; anti-SLAPP statutes (many US states, the EU’s 2024 directive) allow early dismissal and cost-shifting.
  • Source protection — shield laws (most US states, Germany’s §53 StPO) protect journalists from compelled disclosure; they do not protect the source.

MediaMeter context: the Legal domain of our standards registry (LEG-01 to LEG-11) encodes exactly these exposures: defamation risk, privacy, copyright, source protection, court reporting, minors, and DSA misinformation duties.

Last reviewed: October 20, 2026. Part of the MediaMeter knowledge base — editorial reference material, not product documentation.

More from the knowledge base

The ten elements of journalism

Kovach and Rosenstiel's principles for journalism that serves citizens: truth, verification, independence, and the watchdog role — and why they matter more online, not less.

Journalism ethics codes compared

SPJ, NUJ, IFJ, AFP, Reuters, the German Pressekodex and the UK's IPSO code: what the major ethics frameworks require, where they agree, and where they differ.

News values and story strength

How editors decide what is news: Galtung and Ruge's classic factors, David Randall's eight values, and why "say stories" sit at the bottom of the scale.